When I first heard Neil Young’s latest album A Letter
Home I was taken aback by this faint sounding bunch of covers. It was
clearly Neil, and these were songs I was happy to hear him play, but the
quality of the recording was so primitive. I just couldn’t get over it. Why
would he do this? I had only listened to the LP at this point and there lies
the crux of the problem. To fully "get" this album, one has to get
the deluxe version and watch the DVD. As soon as the video comes to life, one
enters a very special session where Neil Young and Jack White embark on an
emotional and technological voyage together. Somehow Jack White has managed to
get the world’s only working example of a “Record Your Voice” booth; a
boardwalk attraction from the 1920’s that looks like a phone booth and allows
any person to sing a song and leave with a hastily pressed record. The records
that the booth itself produced (which also come in the deluxe version) sound
even worse than the LP but are interesting artifacts. So here is this piece of
ancient technology, and Neil Young decides to record a bunch of old favorite
songs on it. Seems simple enough.
When you pop in the DVD however, there is a seamless mixture
of black and white footage whenever Neil is in the booth, but as soon as he
steps out it turns to sumptuous color footage. The audio is also much better.
Neil essentially takes you through the process with him. We see that his songs
are too long to fit on the little automatic records, thus they are running a
line out of the booth so some editing can take place. Suddenly I realized I was
loving this album. Going inside the creative process with these two great
musicians is a rare and wonderful privilege. And make no mistake – Jack White’s
imprint is all over this album. He joins Neil on a couple of songs, singing
harmony, playing piano even playing lead guitar on one song. He is also clearly
playing the role of chief engineer and producer. His deep involvement makes
this an essential item for Jack White fans as much as Neil Young lovers.
As for the material; it is really hard to find fault with
songs like Gordon Lightfoot’s “Early Morning Rain” or “If You Could Read My
Mind,” Phil Ochs’ “Changes,” Tim Hardin’s “Reason To Believe,” Dylan’s “Blowin’
In The Wind,” etc. The songs all clearly mean a lot to Neil and for the most
part he plays them straight and folksy without doing much to make them modern.
And the direct connection to his earlier days is really the point here. Perhaps
the most poignant and important parts of the whole recording are the two
spoken-word pieces he includes. They are short letters to his dead mother. He
explains what he and Jack are doing; playing the songs he used to play when he
lived with her on Grosvenor Ave. as a teen in Canada. In the most touching
moments Neil asks his mother to talk to his father in heaven. They were
divorced long before their deaths, but Neil is trying to fix things for them in
the afterlife. “Remember to talk to Daddy” he pleads. This is a very important
milestone in Neil Young’s career. In a totally non-commercial move he tips his
hat to his heroes, his own past and tries to fill some holes in a broken heart.
- Paul Epstein








The film really has two components. The first is the time they spent together on the soundstage rapping with each other and showing off licks. For instance in one scene (actually found in the bonus material) White teaches the other two one of his signature licks. It is totally simple, but both Page and Edge mutter “brilliant” as they try to play it along with White, who looks like it is not lost on him that he is teaching Jimmy Page and The Edge one of HIS songs, and they are hanging on his every word. The second component follows each guitarist individually as they retrace the steps of their own development as musicians. These moments hold the greatest treats as Page air-guitars to a Link Wray single in his very own man-cave, or The Edge shows us the bulletin board in his high school where U2 drummer Adam Clayton put up a notice for “bandmates wanted” or when Jack White, with the aid of a young actor, teaches himself at 9 years old what the blues are all about. Through deft editing and unprecedented access to the musicians, we get a view of some very famous people as they have never been seen before. They appear, for all the world, to be exactly the same kind of fanboys that those of us who love them actually are. The thrill of seeing Jimmy Page teach the riff from “Kashmir” to two other rock stars is really cool, but to see him as a vulnerable teenager talking about his love for skiffle music and hopes to one day be a medical researcher really opens your eyes to how human these guys are. Yes, Page is the wizard, the most devilish man in rock history, but really, he’s just a kid with a handful of 45’s and a dream to play guitar, and that makes this an incredibly insightful film for people who like their Gods to have feet of clay. I have not enjoyed a movie about rock music as much as this one - maybe ever.